Expert comment - Effective One Health approaches needed for global health security

LSHTM experts reflect on the key take-home messages of the recent Lancet Series on One Health and Global Health Security

Expert quote card

The COVID-19 pandemic has brought into sharper focus the interconnectedness of human health, animal health, and the environment, according to a new Series published in The Lancet.

In doing so, the pandemic has exposed weaknesses in preparedness for public health crises caused by poor coordination between these three spheres — a concept that is core to a ‘One Health’ approach.  

Across four papers, international experts, including from the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine (LSHTM), analysed the current landscape of preventive, surveillance, and response measures to potential public health emergencies, while illuminating how effective adoption of One Health approaches could improve global health security.

The Series presents evidence of the benefits of a One Health approach across a range of hazards, identifying major challenges to effective operationalisation, and providing a comprehensive set of policy and technical recommendations.

Afifah Rahman-Shepherd, Research Fellow at LSHTM specialising in One Heath and Global Health Security and co-author, said:

“It is imperative that One Health networks establish more egalitarian governance structures to ensure inclusive and equitable partnerships and agenda-setting that can address the breadth of One Health issues and serve communities most affected by emerging and existing health security threats.”

A key study in the Series identified issues affecting the sustainability and equity of operationalising One Health through an analysis of such global networks, building on earlier methodology developed by researchers at LSHTM.

The analysis revealed gaps and disparities in the geographic distribution, priorities, and partnership structures of One Health networks, which, without redressing, restrict the extent to which a multisectoral One Health approach is being practiced in reality. For example, the results showed that there are more networks headquartered or operational in Europe than in any other region worldwide, there is insufficient work focusing on upstream drivers of disease emergence and One Health networks are engaging fewer community stakeholders than other types of stakeholders (for example, academic institutions and government bodies).

Mishal Khan, Professor of Global Public Health at LSHTM and co-author, added:

“The One Health approach, as currently operationalised, replicates many of the same asymmetries in power and privilege that characterise the field of global health. This is evident not only in the loci of One Health networks’ decision-making, but also in the voices and priorities that are valued. The issue is not only one of equity but also of how effectively we are able to prevent health emergencies.”

Together the papers in this Series provide a greater understanding of the benefits that can only be achieved through coordination from different sectors working together, and identify ways to address weakness in the operationalisation of One Health.

David Heymann, Professor of Infectious Disease Epidemiology at LSHTM and co-author, said:

“There is no more important time to show what is already being done at the human-animal-environment interface – and what still needs to be done – to prevent or mitigate the emergence of another virus of animal origin. There must be a shift in the paradigm from rapid detection and response (and the associated human and economic costs), to prevention at or near the source. 

“This Lancet Series is timely and practical because it highlights experience not only in industrialised countries, but in lower and middle income countries as represented by its authors. It will be useful to both political and technical leaders, and provides a way to move the sentinel population for emergence upstream, from humans to the source in nature.” 

Further information

The Lancet are hosting a free and open-to-all webinar launch event for the Series at 13:00-15:00 GMT on Thursday 26 January. Register to attend here.

If you are interested in studying for the MSc in One Health: ecosystems, humans and animals at LSHTM, registration is now open for our virtual open days taking place 7-8 February.

Short courses

LSHTM's short and specifically designed courses provide the opportunity for intensive study in specialised topics.

These courses enable participants to refresh their skills and keep up to date with the latest research and knowledge in public and global health.